Offerings
Kitchen Witch Crafts
Morning Treats
Or eat them whenever. We're not the boss of you.
Blueberry muffin
Filled to the brim with blueberries and topped with a cinnamon streusel topping.
$5
Double Chocolate Zucchini muffin
The reason my kids call me a kitchen witch. I wave my magic whisk and turn zucchini into a delicious chocolaty treat.
$5
Pumpkin muffin
At Mystic Oven, Pumpkin spice season lasts all year long.
$5
Pumpkin Pecan Muffin
$5
Cookies
Brown Butter Chocolate chip
$3.50
Brown Butter White Chocolate Macadamia Nut
$3.50
Naked Sugar
Plain sugar cookies speckled with vanilla beans.
$3.50
Dressed Sugar
Iced Sugar cookies
$4.50
Specialties
Brownies
Extra fudgy brownies made with Ghirardelli chocolate
$5
Blondies
White chocolate blondies with macadamia nuts topped with flaky sea salt.
$5
Salted caramel brownies
Rich fudgy brownies topped with a ribbon of our house made creme brûlée caramel and flaky sea salt.
$6
Red Velvet Cupcake
No red dye used. Original recipe creates a subtle red color from the reaction of cocoa and buttermilk.
$5
Vanilla Cupcake
Vanilla cake topped with vanilla buttercream
$5
Chocolate Cupcake
Chocolate cake topped with chocolate buttercream.
$5
Add caramel sauce
$1
Coven sized
Let Mystic Oven bring some magic to your next gathering. Serves 13.
48 hour notice for standard orders. 7 day notice for customized orders.
Brownies/Blondies
$45
Cookies
Brown butter chocolate chip, brown butter white chocolate macadamia nut and sugar cookies.
w/naked sugar cookies
$35
w/dressed sugar cookies
$45
Standard Cupcakes
$50
Morning Treats
$50
Custom Cupcakes
$60
Custom Dressed Sugar Cookies
$55
Minis
Mini Muffins
$2.50
Mini Cupcakes
$2.50
Mix and match dozen
Muffins and cupcakes only.
$25
Mini Cake
$10
Cakes
Cake Flavors: vanilla, chocolate and red velvet
Buttercream flavors: vanilla, chocolate and cream cheese.
4 inch cake
Serves 8
$25
6 inch round
Serves 12
$35
8 inch round
Serves 16
$45